Representative-elect Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez has compared immigrants trying to cross the border into the United States, to the baby Jesus.
In a Christmas tweet she told her followers to remember that Jesus and his family were refugees too.
You can unsubscribe any time. By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use.
The Independent reports: Although Jesus was most likely not born in December, Christmas is meant to represent the birth of Jesus Christ, often portrayed in holiday decorations in a manger. After Jesus’ birth, his parents Mary and Joseph had to flee the country in order to escape a massacre.
Similarly, Central American immigrants are fleeing their own countries to settle in the United States, many of whom are hoping to claim asylum. However, political tensions, military personnel sent to the border, migrant caravans, and demands for wall funding are putting immigrants at the centre of contentious debate. President Donald Trump even signed an executive order targeting refugees and Muslims in January of 2017.
In a tweet addressed to “anti-immigration pundits,” Ms Ocasio-Cortez points to an article in America Magazine explaining how Jesus, Mary, and Joseph were refugees. Pope Francis agrees.
However, not everyone sees the value in comparing Jesus Christ to immigrants crossing the border, which critics point out as, in some cases, illegal. Conservative political commentator Dinesh D’Souza tweeted his contentions that the Holy Family was not “a group of illegal aliens.”
Sorry @Ocasio2018 but if Joseph and Mary traveled to Bethlehem to register for the Roman census, how does that make the Holy Family a group of illegal aliens?
— Dinesh D’Souza (@DineshDSouza) December 26, 2018
Other Twitter users also attacked Ocasio-Cortez, arguing that Mary and Joseph had not travelled from Nazareth to Bethlehem as immigrants, but to enroll in a census. Therefore, the scene of Baby Jesus in a manger is not a scene of desperate refugees. However, others argue that the family’s subsequent night-time departure to Egypt is where they become immigrant refugees.
In response to the criticisms, Ms Ocasio-Cortez posted an image of a painting by artist Kelly Latimore that appears to depict immigrants travelling at night. Halos around the subjects appear to link them to religious figures.
True love is radical because it requires us to see ourselves in all people. Otherwise, it isn’t love.
Love is revolutionary because it has us treat ALL people as we would ourselves – not because we are charitable, but because we are one.
That is love’s radical conclusion. pic.twitter.com/IB5q0ko8VQ
— Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (@Ocasio2018) December 26, 2018
Niamh Harris